Shelter Island Craft Brewery, Shelter Island

#6 of 6 in Breweries & Distilleries in Hamptons
Brewery · Hidden Gem · Food & Drink
Shelter Island Craft Brewery is located in Shelter Island. Arrange to visit Shelter Island Craft Brewery and other attractions in Shelter Island using our Shelter Island trip planner.
Create an itinerary including Shelter Island Craft Brewery
© OpenMapTiles © OpenStreetMap contributors

Shelter Island Craft Brewery reviews

Rate this attraction
TripAdvisor traveler rating
TripAdvisor traveler rating 3.5
28 reviews
  • Wanted to reviewe this place more for service then beer. The beer was ok (the 114 flagship). So we walked from the north ferry to this brewery, should have rented a bike or a car even. Didn't quite....  more »
  • So wanted to like this place because of excellent comfortable decor and helpful staff, but just could not find a beer I liked. And I tried many. I could not make myself finish the one purchased...  more »
  • I’m a huge fan of local craft breweries and passing by Shelter Island I thought it would be nice to stop by this establishment. But I regret to say this is not really a place worth visit, sorry. Tasting wasn’t available when I stopped by, the beer I did try was actually quite horrible (was it something wrong with it? maybe?!) and also the staff wasn’t very friendly or helpful. If looking for craft beer in the area I would skip this place and go to Greenport instead.
  • Quiet afternoon stopped in right before closing. My girlfriend and I both taster two beers and chose one of those two. They were fun to try as a craft beer but I probably wouldn’t get a six pack. Staff was friendly. We shared a quick couple of good stories as they were cleaning up. As another review said, if you’re on the island it’s worth stopping by... I agree.
  • Build a trip
    Tell us where and when you
    want to go, we will build
    the best sightseeing itinerary
  • Refine it
    You have complete flexibility on your destinations and itinerary
  • Book as a package
    Use our travel agents to get
    package savings and hassle free booking
  • Enjoy your trip!
    Enjoy our 24x7
    on-trip assistance